Peanut Butter Bullseye vs. Peanut Butter Cup: A Memphis Ice Cream Guide

If you are choosing between Peanut Butter Bullseye and Peanut Butter Cup at Sweet Escape, the names suggest a close family resemblance. The useful question is what the published records actually confirm. Both are listed as ice cream in Sweet Escape’s scoop catalog, and each has its own nutrition and allergen record. The available data lets us compare serving basis, selected nutrition values, and cautions. It does not give a full sensory description for either flavor, so this guide will not invent one.

That distinction makes the comparison more practical, not less: you can see where the records are alike, where their listed numbers differ, what the names cannot tell you, and where to verify current details. The latest stock snapshot available while preparing this article listed both flavors; because a stock list can change, use the live in-stock menu for the final check before a Memphis visit.

The quick comparison

Both entries are ice cream and both records use a 2/3-cup (95-gram) serving. The product pages link to separate pages of Sweet Escape’s published nutrition document. Those records show a few numerical differences, but they do not describe how either flavor tastes or what makes its recipe distinct. Think of the table as a guide to the information on file—not a ranking or a promise about a serving scooped in the shop.

The product pages link to the label pages for Peanut Butter Bullseye and Peanut Butter Cup. Their underlying source records are dated June 18, 2019. Formulas and container labels can change, so regard those published values as reference information and ask the shop to verify the current label when the details matter to your decision.

What the names tell you—and what they do not

The catalog and product cards identify two separately named ice-cream flavors: Peanut Butter Bullseye and Peanut Butter Cup. Their displayed descriptions are brief catalog identifiers, not detailed tasting notes or ingredient lists. The names alone are not enough to state that one has a particular center, ribbon, candy piece, texture, or balance of chocolate and peanut butter. Those might sound like plausible expectations from the names, but they are not documented facts in the records reviewed for this guide.

That is why the comparison starts with the exact product pages. A flavor title can help you find the right record, while the fields on that record tell you what is actually published. Here, the records confirm category, nutrition values, and allergen information. They do not provide a verified paragraph distinguishing the recipes. If a specific ingredient or preparation detail would decide your order, ask Sweet Escape about the current product label rather than filling the gap with a guess.

There are other peanut-butter-named products in the broader catalog, too. They should not be blended into these two entries. For example, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Swirl is a separate catalog item with its own description and product-line record; it is not evidence for what Peanut Butter Cup or Peanut Butter Bullseye contains. Our scoop catalog and complete item directory keep those product names linked to their own pages.

How to read the nutrition comparison fairly

The listed serving basis is the same for both records: 2/3 cup, or 95 grams. That makes the numbers directly comparable as published. Peanut Butter Cup’s record lists 20 more calories, 2 grams more total fat, 1 gram less saturated fat, and 90 milligrams more sodium than Peanut Butter Bullseye’s record. It lists 1 gram less total carbohydrate, 2 grams less total sugar, and 1 gram more protein.

These are descriptions of the figures shown on the records, not advice about what anyone should choose. A difference in a listed value does not make one flavor “healthier,” and a nutrition panel does not measure what an individual person needs. If you compare the labels, compare like with like: the stated serving basis matters, and the record values are not a measurement of the particular scoop served to you.

The table leaves out other values that appear on the product pages, such as cholesterol, trans fat, fiber, and added sugars. You can review all published fields and open the linked nutrition label from each individual card. The nutrition and allergen guide explains how Sweet Escape separates those fields. Rather than using one number as a shortcut, read the complete record that corresponds to the exact flavor you are considering.

Both source pages are part of a document whose product data is dated 2019. That date is important context: an online record is helpful for comparing what Sweet Escape has published, but it should not replace checking current packaging or asking the shop when an ingredient, formulation, or nutrition detail is essential. The product pages themselves also caution that recipes and labels can change.

Allergen details: similar records, same need to verify

Both product pages list milk, peanuts, and soy under “Contains.” Both also carry an equipment note naming tree nuts, wheat, and eggs. These are important distinctions to preserve exactly. The equipment note is separate from the declared ingredients in the “Contains” field; do not collapse the two into a claim that an item is free from any other allergen or safe for a particular person.

A product name is never an allergy check. Nor does a comparison between two peanut-butter flavors establish a safe choice for someone with a peanut, milk, soy, tree-nut, wheat, or egg concern. The records are dated, recipes and labels may change, and online information cannot guarantee the absence of cross-contact during handling.

If an allergy or dietary requirement affects the order, open the exact product page and then ask the shop to verify the current container label and relevant handling information before deciding. The nut-named flavor and allergen guide offers more detail on reading those cautions. A blank or brief product description is not evidence that an ingredient or cross-contact risk is absent.

Which one should you choose?

Start with what matters to you and use the records for the decision they can support. If you are comparing published nutrition information, both pages make it possible to compare values on the same stated portion basis. If an allergen is relevant, the records show matching declared and equipment cautions, but you should still verify the current label. If what you want to know is a specific flavor or texture difference, the available catalog descriptions do not answer that question in enough detail for us to declare a winner.

That does not mean you have to choose blindly. You can ask whether the current labels or product information explain how the flavors differ, and then choose based on the answer and the item that is actually available. If the distinction is not documented, it is completely reasonable to order by the name that appeals to you or ask the shop what it can confirm—without treating a guess as a guarantee.

Sweet Escape publishes many distinct scoop records, so a similar name does not mean two items are interchangeable. Check that the full product name on the live menu matches the card you opened. This small step is especially helpful when searching by a short phrase like “peanut butter,” since several items may appear in the wider catalog but not in the current in-stock list.

Check availability separately from the catalog

When this article was prepared, the repository’s latest stock snapshot was timestamped October 2, 2026 at 19:05 UTC (2:05 p.m. Central Daylight Time) and included both Peanut Butter Bullseye and Peanut Butter Cup. That is a dated snapshot, not a promise that either flavor will still be listed when you arrive. The live menu is the right place to check the latest published selection.

Availability and product description answer different questions. A flavor page documents a product; the in-stock page reports the latest posted selection. You may need both: first use the live list to see whether the flavor is currently posted, then open the matching item page to review its nutrition and allergen details. If the menu changes or the product you want is not listed, call the shop rather than assuming the catalog guarantees it.

Sweet Escape is at 1674 Whitten Road, Suite 106, Memphis, TN 38134, near Bartlett. The Visit page has the regular hours, directions, and phone number, (901) 718-5812. Use that page for trip details and the stock page for the current menu; neither this article nor a catalog entry is a reservation or availability promise.

Frequently asked questions

Are Peanut Butter Bullseye and Peanut Butter Cup the same flavor?

Sweet Escape lists them as separate ice-cream products with separate nutrition records. The published descriptions do not establish a specific sensory difference beyond the separate product names and records.

Are both flavors on the live menu?

The latest stock snapshot available when this guide was prepared listed both. Stock can change, so check the live in-stock menu before visiting.

What allergens are listed?

Both records list milk, peanuts, and soy as contained allergens, with a shared-equipment note for tree nuts, wheat, and eggs. Verify current container labels and handling with the shop when an allergy matters.